Hi friends, and welcome back to Talmud Daily, our 40-week tour throughout the entire Babylonian Talmud. And today, I want to talk a little bit about the holiday that we refer to as Rosh Hashanah, as well as try to understand more deeply why is it that we have a lunar-solar calendar. What is the deeper conceptual meaning that we always try to integrate both the months and the seasons, the lunar and the solar, together?
Let’s begin with the holiday that we know as Rosh Hashanah, the name for the tractate that we are exploring this week. So it’s very strange. For most holidays, the first question that anybody would really ask is like, well, what happened on this day? The first mishnah in Rosh Hashanah takes it as a given that this is the beginning of the year, so to speak, for humanity, where humanity, so to speak, has this judgment day and we pass before God. But where does that come from, and where does… like what does this day commemorate? Why this day?
There is a dispute over when the world was created, and this dispute takes place in our tractate on page 10b, and that is a dispute between Rebbi Eliezer and Rebbi Yehoshua—they’re very often in dialogue with each other. Rebbi Eliezer says on Tishrei, the first of Tishrei, is when the world was created, while Rebbi Yehoshua says the world was created in Nissan. As Tosafos points out, there’s truth to both of these opinions. Tosafos invokes the phrase that we heard and we discussed when we explored Tractate Eruvin, and that is the phrase eilu v’eilu divrei Elokim chayim, these and these are words of the living God. Meaning there’s truth to both of these opinions.
In one sense, if you think about Nissan is when the Jewish people were created. As opposed to Tishrei, it is when, I guess, the world was created. But if you look a little bit more deeply, the Ran… The Ran is an acronym for Rabbeinu Nissim. The Ran is one of the great commentaries on the Talmud and lived in the 14th century. So it was kind of like on the later side. It’s a few hundred years. That’s like three, 400 years after Rashi and Maimonides. They were like the early commentaries, but there was this period where people were really just trying to get their bearing straight of what the Talmud. We call this period the Rishonim, the early ones. These were the Tosafos, Rashi, Rambam, and one of the great ones, of course, is the Ran.
And the Ran asks in Tractate Rosh Hashanah… You could find the commentary of the Ran if you’re looking, if you have a classical Rosh Hashanah, you can look in the back and it’s one of the commentaries on the Rif, Rabbeinu Alfasi. But let’s not get caught with all of that, and let’s just present the question of the Ran.
The Ran, the Ran wants to know, so like what is the deal with Rosh Hashanah? Was the world, in fact, created this day? And the Ran cites, and this has become really like canon for understanding what Rosh Hashanah is all about. The Ran, drawing from a midrash, the Ran says the world wasn’t created on the first of Tishrei. The world was actually created on the 25th of Elul. So six days later is the first of Tishrei.
So what happened on the first of Tishrei? Man was created. This is the story in Genesis, where you can look at the first three chapters of Genesis, which talk about the creation of the world and creation of man. Man was created on the Friday of creation. That is when humanity was created.
But if you look at something, and this will really unlock quite a bit, and I discuss this. This is awful that I’m doing this now, but we’re having fun here, why not? I actually wrote a book. This is a book that I wrote. It’s called Sin-a-gogue: Sin and Failure in Jewish Thought. Cute little pun there. And in this book, I have a chapter, the second chapter, called “Sin’s Origin and Original Sin.” And in that chapter, I discuss the sin of Adam eating from the tree of knowledge.
Now, why are we talking about this? Because this, I believe, is one of the great differences between Judaism and other Abrahamic religions. If you read a plain reading of Genesis, and you open up the third chapter of Genesis, which is the story of Adam and Eve eating from the tree of knowledge, I want to ask a basic question on this story. There are a million questions you could ask, but we don’t have time for all of them. You could ask, how could they have sinned? They were just created. What was the sin? They just ate from a tree. Why would they would have sinned? There are so many questions you could ask.
I think the most fundamental question for our discussion, and we’re talking about Tractate Rosh Hashanah and the calendar, is not what was the sin, it’s not why did he sin, it’s not how did he sin. It is when did he sin? And here is where I believe the Jewish faith departs from other religious understandings of this story. The typical understanding of this story, and I’ve asked Christian scholars and they all basically feel this way. When did this story take place? And they will tell you God created a perfect world, and this took place after creation. How long after? Maybe it was Sunday morning brunch, maybe it was a few weeks later, maybe it was a few months later.
In the Jewish tradition, we deliberately, and the Talmud says this both in Tractate Sanhedrin as well as many different Midrashic texts, all date the story of Adam and Eve eating from the Tree of Knowledge on that Friday. That is when it happened. It was on the sixth day of creation. The day that Adam was created is also the day that he ate from the Tree of Knowledge. Which means that Rosh Hashanah is not just the anniversary of the creation of man, it is also the anniversary, so to speak, of that infamous event of Adam eating from the tree.
Now, we can’t unpack the entirety of this story, but there’s one thing that I want to mention. If you look at this story, you will notice that it is bookended with one experience, one word, and that is the word known as bushah, being embarrassed. The story begins with Adam is totally naked, doesn’t realize he’s naked, he’s not embarrassed, and after eating from the tree, the first consequence that Adam realizes is, “Oh, I am embarrassed, I am now naked.” Embarrassment is the bookend of this story. In a way, our capacity to feel embarrassment emerges from this story. What does it mean to feel embarrassed? What does it mean to experience, in the Hebrew term, bushah, which features so prominently in this story?
So, first, I want to highlight one very important thing. If you date the story of Adam eating from the Tree of Knowledge on the day that Adam was created, it is not only the anniversary of Rosh Hashanah, but it leads to a drastically different understanding of time and the world.
There’s one understanding where God creates the world that is totally perfect, because everything related to God is perfect, and it is man who corrupts God’s perfect world. This is a more classical Christian reading of the story. Man corrupts God’s perfection, which means that perfection is always a function of the past. We need to retrieve the perfect world, to go back and retrieve the perfect world, that God created.
The Jewish reading is very different. The Jewish reading is that this act of corruption, this act of experiencing embarrassment, took place on the day where Adam was created, which means that almost in the creation story itself, the world is imperfect. The world was created imperfectly, which means that perfection is always a future orientation. And this is very much the Jewish mindset, which is perfection is not something we need to retrieve from the past, but is something we, humanity, need to build for our own future. We’re always reaching towards perfection.
So what is it about bushah? Why is this the consequence, the bookend of this story? What makes somebody feel embarrassed? If somebody walked up to me and started laughing and say, “Haha, you’re not a billionaire,” I wouldn’t really think much of it. I’m like, “You know, I know you’re right.” Somebody walked up to me and said, “Haha, you are not an astrophysicist. You are not a NASA pilot.” I’d be like, “That’s not embarrassing at all, I know that.”
Embarrassment is when we feel our inner sense of self and our outer sense of self are dissonant with one another. It’s when I feel I’m a good writer and then somebody outside is snickering and says, “This guy does not know how to write,” and everybody’s laughing. That would embarrass me deeply. If I think that I’m a great basketball player and then I slip on the court, that would embarrass me deeply. It is when there is a dissonance between our inner sense of self and our outer sense of self. That’s why it shouldn’t be a coincidence that the word bushah appears later on in the 32nd chapter of Exodus, which is actually the beginning of the story of the golden calf. We’re starting to get to much more depth. We’re not going to go into this. But the word bushah in that context, and it appears right over there in the beginning of the 32nd chapter, actually means to be delayed, to have that dissonance between an inner self and an outer sense. I want to have that promotion already, I want to be married already, I want to have a professional milestone already. We feel bushah when there is a delay, when there is a dissonance between what we feel inside and the cues that we’re getting from the outside.
And this, I believe, is the deeper meaning behind the Jewish calendar and why we deliberately have a solar and lunar calendar. There is a difference between the sun and the moon. The sun always appears to us full in the sky. It illuminates everything. We feel the warmth of the sun. We feel the daylight and the clarity of the sun. The sun represents our sense of self that is static. That we feel like we’ve already arrived. Who we are already exists. I don’t need to earn and discover who I am. Dovid Bashevkin and each of us, our individual sense of self, is real and is fully arrived and fully developed.
But there is another sense of self, and this kind of emerges from the story of Adam eating from the Tree of Knowledge itself, and that is the capacity for bushah, for embarrassment. And that’s the sense of self that is like the moon—that is always waxing and waning. Where we feel—some days we feel great, some days we feel low, some days we feel like we’re exactly on the right track, and sometimes it feels like we’re totally lost.
This is the idea of the month, which literally in Hebrew is a chodesh, which is the same term as chadash, which means newness. We’re always rediscovering. We’re waxing, we’re waning, we’re up and we’re down. We really have two senses of self. We have one sense of self that is static and clear and we feel exactly where we are and who we are, fully arrived, that’s represented by the sun. But the way we really experience life is much more like the moon. We’re waxing and we’re waning. We have times where we feel full, or times where we only feel like we see a sliver of ourselves.
And what does the Jewish calendar do? The Jewish calendar weds these two together, because this is how we’re supposed to experience time. Even though we’re unfolding every single day and we’re learning more about ourselves, and we’re arriving closer and closer to our fully actualized self, that entire journey, that entire process, we still feel like a moon, where we have days where we only feel like a sliver, we have moments where we feel entirely absent, and then we have great moments where we feel full, but it’s always changing. What the Jewish calendar does is it weds the sun and the moon together and always keeps them in step to realize that the journey, becoming, the process, is always linked to that ultimate destination. Our static identity, that inherent self-worth, that the sun represents is always linked and always connected to that becoming, that journey, that only sliver of having a self.
And the beauty of the Jewish conception of time and how we sanctify time is that being and becoming, the sun and the moon, are always linked together. And this is the way, when we fully realize this, this is our answer to the ultimate deficiency of humanity that we don’t know who we are or what we’re going to become. This is what emerged from that original sin of eating from the tree of knowledge, from that capacity to experience embarrassment, that capacity to have a dissonance between our inner world and our outer world. What the Jewish approach to time does is it links them together.
Our sun—the clarity, the staticness, the full arrival—and our moon—the waxing and the waning, the becoming. Being and becoming are always linked together, and that is the beauty of Jewish time and the Jewish calendar.
So thank you so much for listening to Talmud Daily, and let’s together keep making Torah sweet.