Hi friends, and welcome back to Talmud Daily, our 40-week tour in just 10 minutes a day of the entire Talmud. And today, I want to share a little bit about the history of Eruvin.
Now, there is a classic joke that you may have heard, but I think it is really paradigmatic of everything about the tractate. And it’s about this person who’s converting to Judaism, and this person who says, “Look, I’m only going to keep a full Shabbos once I’m Jewish, and when I’m not Jewish, I’m not yet involved in Shabbos.” So, every week, he makes sure not to keep a full Shabbos.
And one week, somebody asks him, he says, “I don’t get it. Like, what did you do this week to like make sure that like the full Shabbos is only when you are fully converted?” He says, “What are you talking about? I hadmy keys in my pocket the whole Shabbos. So, I was walking around carrying.” So, the person looks at him, says, “No, no, no. We have an eruv in our community.” So, he looks at him and says, “Ugh, that eruv? Feh! I don’t hold of the eruv. I don’t believe in that eruv.”
So, what is this making a joke out of? It’s making a joke out of the divisiveness that very often emerges from the question of eruv. And unfortunately, I don’t think that this divisiveness is an accident. I actually think it is a feature of Tractate Eruvin.
As we mentioned about the deeper meaning of eruvin, there is a reason why the question of eilu v’eilu divrei Elokim chayim, these and these are words of the living God, of trying to figure out when there’s an argument, seeing divinity in both. The way Reb Tzadok explains this, this is about our own individual opinion and figuring out how to wed it and integrate it into the, so to speak, reshus harabbim, the collective truth, the supernal truth. And then we have our individual opinion. And when they butt up, which is what eruvin is all about, transforming and integrating private domains and public domains, there’s going to be debate, and there’s going to be divisiveness. And sometimes, very sadly, it can escalate and become very antagonistic and very adversarial.
There is a long history of fights over eruvin, and there are really two different types of fights. There are one fights where people who don’t want any eruv at all because they’re worried about how it’s going to change the character of the community. “We don’t want, you know, all these people with strollers in the street” or whatever they associate with a Shabbos-observant community. Now, this has happened in multiple places, and there have been a ton of court cases about it that you can actually read. Almost always, the eruv is deemed legal, and the people who are pushing up against the eruv are seen to be infringing on the free exercise clause, at least when this happens in the United States of America.
There is an absolutely wonderful book that has an entire chapter on the inner fight over an eruv, and it examines the fight over the Columbus eruv. Now, my wife is from Columbus, so I love Columbus. I love everybody from there. I’m not looking to rehash what is likely a very painful memories for a lot of people. And this is lived memory, meaning there are people alive now who probably remember some of these really, really difficult fights. There was another very famous fight that went to court in Tenafly, New Jersey, That’s like 10 minutes from my home.
But there is a wonderful book that explores the fight over the Columbus eruv that I would like to share with you, and that is called Jew vs. Jew by Samuel Freedman. Samuel Freedman is a brilliant writer. He’s a professor in the Columbia School of Journalism. I’ve actually interviewed him on 18Forty. Aa really, really wonderful thinker. And he has an entire chapter on the battle that took place in—oh, not Columbus, Ohio. Beachwood, Ohio! My mistake, I’m so sorry—in Beachwood, Ohio over the eruv.
And it really sometimes is a battle over the character of a neighborhood. You know, which can have some ugly themes come up in there, but it relates to what the function of an eruv is. They’re right. The eruv is creating community. It’s creating communal boundaries. So, I would read that chapter if you want to get an inside look at some of the more contentious, emotional triggers that emerge when some peoplehear for the first timewe want to build an eruv in a community that previously did not have one. It triggers a lot of people’s religious memories and what they associate with either Judaism, or Orthodox Judaism, or traditional Judaism, or Shabbos. And we all carry stuff, and it doesn’t surprise me that specifically eruv, which relates to the actual character of a community, can become so, so incredibly contentious.
There is another book that I would also like to recommend, and this is really about the history of eruv, and it is wonderful. And this is a book by Rabbi Adam Mintz called Building Communities: A History of the Eruv in America. And this is really fascinating because it is not just about eruv, but it is really about American Jewish history: talking about the eruv in St. Louis, the eruv in Toronto, and, most famously, the debate over the Manhattan eruv.
Now I want to talk a little bit about this. The Manhattan eruv, and similarly the eruv in in Flatbush in Brooklyn, is extraordinarily contentious. There are a lot of people who do not, like the joke goes, “Feh, I don’t hold of the eruv.” They will not carry and use the eruv in in certain parts of the city, in any parts in the city. There are so many people who do different things.
Now, why is this eruv so contentious? I want to introduce one other factor in building an eruv. As we mentioned, you cannot build an eruv in a public domain. A private domain does not need an eruv. We build what we call the eruv with the string around that ambiguous middle area, what’s known as a karmelis.
But there is another factor at play in what may define a public domain, which would make it impossible. If it’s a public domain, you can put as much string around it as you want. [It] doesn’t do anything. It’s only in the ambiguous rabbinically prohibited domain that we allow for the stringed eruv. In an actual biblically prohibited public domain, you can’t carry. It doesn’t matter how much string there is.
So there’s one other factor, and that’s what makes the Manhattan eruv so contentious, and that is, everything about eruv, as we said, and all of the prohibitions of Shabbos, are modeled after the Jewish people’s sojourn in the desert. That you can look in the 35th chapter of Exodus, in the beginning of what’s known as Parshas Vayakhel.
But there is another factor that may be in place, and that is the count of Jews that were in the public domain of the desert in that time is generally known as 600,000. That’s the count that we’re given of people who are of fighting age and all the counts in the Torah we have. There were 600,000 people there. And the Shulchan Aruch actually, the great code of Jewish law, actually writes that one of the conditions, the actual conditions, to be a public domain is 600,000 people. 600,000 people makes it a public domain and therefore makes it impossible to build an eruv.
Now the question is, how do you come up with that 600,000 figure? Is that just a neighborhood that has 600,000 people? Is it a street? I live on a busy street. We don’t have 600,000 cars that are going through our street, you know, even if it is busier than I would like. The question is, how do we understand this condition of requiring 600,000?
Rav Moshe Feinstein lived in Luban, which is in like a Belarus, but immigrated to America right before the Holocaust, I believe, or maybe immediately after, in the 1940s, I believe. And Rav Moshe Feinstein became really the consensus builder of how to wed modern North American Jewish life to halacha and Talmud and all of the traditions. He became the address. And I’m sure we’re going to talk a great deal about Rav Moshe Feinstein, because really one of the great personalities, thinkers, and scholars who brought Talmudic learning into the 21st century. I mean really stands alone and built an incredible consensus where to this day in America, when you’re thinking about, you know, halacha, the name that people talk about, that just is like this is what Rav Moshe Feinstein recommended.
It was really at a time of—a very transitional time. It’s when European Jewry had collapsed and was decimated in the Holocaust, and now America needed to become the new place where we turned to for authentic religious Jewish guidance and Jewish practice. And Rav Moshe Feinstein really stepped into an incredible leadership role.
But Rav Moshe Feinstein was not a fan, would prohibit it, did not want an eruv in Manhattan. [He]felt that the number 600,000 is not just on any individual thoroughfare, but it’s the neighborhood in general. And Manhattan, even at the time that Rav Moshe Feinstein lived in there, already exceeded two million people. So Rav Moshe Feinstein actually said we should not be building an eruv in Manhattan.
A lot of these questions have to do with [the question of] are we going to forget the prohibition of carrying and going out on Shabbos altogether? Because if everywhere has an eruv—where there are people who are incredibly lenient in this because really it’s nearly impossible to function on Shabbos without an eruv. Though I’ve done it, you know, sometimes I go on vacation. I remember when we would go to New Hampshire in the summertime, there wouldn’t be an eruv, so you really have to adjust to it very, very quickly, and it could be very, very difficult for people.
So Rav Moshe Feinstein said Manhattan is far too big to build an eruv because of this condition of 600,000 and the way that he applied it to the population rather than any individual thoroughfare. And that is why, for many people, Brooklyn and Manhattan, the eruv is extraordinarily contentious. There are eruvin there, and I think there are very good, decent holy people who still carry. We’re not, I’m not giving anybody advice on what they should do. You should speak to your local rabbi for your individual practice. But the history, there is no question, that there were two types of contentiousness that emerge from eruvin, and I don’t think it’s a coincidence.
One type of contentiousness are lawsuits, like the story in Jew vs. Jew Beachwood, Ohio, Tenafly. These are lawsuits that are trying to prevent any eruv whatsoever. But there is a different type of adversarialness that can sometimes come out, and that is when one rabbi takes a more prohibitive stance, like especially when RavMoshe Feinstein prohibited the eiruv in Manhattan, and then other rabbis may come along after and say, “Look, we’re not going to be able to function like this, we’re going to need something.” And they may build other eruvin.And then you have communities where some people do use the eruv, some people don’t do the eruv, and that can lead to other types of divisions.
But this makes sense if you understand what Eruvin is about. Eiruvin is about building community. When you bring community together. If you’ve ever been to a public board hearing in your local community, you’ve been to a school board meeting. when you bring community together, when you bring a lot of reshus hayachids, a lot of individuals, together into this reshus harabbim, there’s going to be butting of the heads. It’s when every individual’s practicality, sensitivities start, you know, different people are going to have different sensitivities, different opinions. It’s when the individual starts to butt up or figure out how am I going to be integrated into the collective? And that really is the heart of Tractate Eiruvin, which is: How do we integrate, how do we negotiate between private and public spaces? Which is really why, more conceptually, why our tractate, as we mentioned, is also the tractate, one of only two in the entire Talmud, that gives this transcendent principle of eilu v’eilu divrei Elokim chayim.Of being able to see divinity in both opinions—the one who is against,the one who is pro—in understanding the values, ideas, and of course the history behind all of these Talmudic concepts.
So thank you so much for listening to Talmud Daily, and let’s keep making Torah sweet.