Episodes / Moed · Rosh Hashanah · Mon
Day 56 of 164

How the Jewish Calendar Became a Guinness World Record

Twelve lunar months leave us about eleven days short of a solar year. What do we do with those eleven days?

10:27 · Nov 9, 2026
Hosted by Dovid Bashevkin
Day 55
Day 57
In this episode

Take out your calculator. Twelve lunar months add up to about 354 days. A solar year takes about 365. So what happens if we build our calendar around the moon alone? Pesach would come about eleven days earlier each year. Give it a few years and we’d be sitting down to the Seder in winter.

So why don’t we just use a solar calendar? That would keep Pesach in spring. But think about April 1. A new moon is how we mark a new month. What does a date like April 1 tell you about the moon? You could look up and see a full moon, a thin crescent, or no moon at all.

Before we even leave Egypt, the Torah gives us our first mitzvah as a people. Hachodesh hazeh lachem. This month, Nissan, is yours. Then the Torah tells us Shamor es chodesh ha-aviv. Guard the month of spring. Nissan has to follow the moon and still arrive in spring.

How do we keep both? Seven times in nineteen years, we add an extra month—a second Adar. We call that ibbur, literally pregnancy. The year carries an extra month so Pesach can stay in its season. And yes, this is the calendar Guinness calls the oldest still in use.

Sources referenced
Transcript
Read the full transcript

Hi friends, and welcome back to Talmud Daily, our 40-week tour throughout the entire Babylonian Talmud. And this week we are exploring Tractate Rosh Hashanah, and I am so excited to introduce this tractate to you, because (drumroll, please) I believe this is the only tractate which discusses something—people don’t know this—that the Jewish people are Guinness Book of World Record holders. What? What Guinness Book of World Records do you think the Jewish people, the Jewish people as a whole, actually have? And I find this so incredibly moving, because, you know what? I’m going to say it out loud: I actually believe in Judaism. I think this stuff is real. And we have the Guinness Book of World Records for the oldest calendar still in use. That the Jewish people have been using our calendar longer than any other calendar. That it is still in use uninterrupted. I think that’s amazing.

And really at the heart of Tractate Rosh Hashanah, which again, pause. Rosh Hashanah, you’re probably familiar with, is a holiday at the beginning of the year. It is literally Rosh Hashanah, the head of the new year. But you will open up the first mishnah in Rosh Hashanah, and you will see we have many different new years. We have the new years for humanity, we have the new year for trees. To really understand what it means—a new year—we really have to understand how the Jewish calendar works, and the place where the Jewish calendar is explained, is described, how we sanctified it, is Tractate Rosh Hashanah.

So first and foremost, it’s important to understand that sanctifying time, sanctifying the calendar, is actually a religious obligation. This is a religious commandment. Jews take time very seriously. In fact, the first mitzvah, the first commandment, that the Jewish people are given as a people, after, you know. I think we’re still in Egypt at the time. But is in the 12th chapter of Exodus, and the Jewish people are told, Hachodesh hazeh lachem, this month, it’s actually referring to the month of Nissan, this month is Rosh Chodashim, rishon hu lachem lechodshei hashanah. This month is going to be the beginning of months—not talking about Rosh Hashanah—but it is explaining that the first commandment we’re given is to sanctify the months, to sanctify our calendar.

Now, I want to explain the Jewish calendar, because on a personal level it was always a mystery to me, and the Jewish calendar, I genuinely believe, is both philosophically, and just how it works, is so brilliant and is so powerful. So let’s explain how the Jewish calendar works, and then throughout the week we’ll get into Rosh Hashanah and some of the other really exciting topics that emerge from this very tractate.

Now, everyone knows there are really three ways that we measure time, and only two are really reflected in the astronomy. I mean, there’re more than three ways, but three like groups, major groups on a calendar.

On a calendar you will see the week is a seven-day cycle. It’s not totally clear how we came to the seven-day cycle. I certainly think it has something to do with Shabbos. We don’t really have any great explanations for how we came to the seven-day cycle. I’m talking about in scholarship. In the Jewish world, it makes a lot of sense why we have a seven-day cycle. That’s the seven days of creation, the last day being Shabbos.

But on a calendar, you will see every week, and then on the next thing you’ll see on the calendar is the month, right? The month is a very real cycle. Where do we get months from? It takes 29 and a half days, more or less, for the moon to revolve around the Earth. This is the lunar cycle: 29 and a half days, and that is about a month, more or less. The sun, and this is a solar calendar, the sun takes 365 days, more or less, where the Earth revolves around the sun, and that revolution of the Earth around the sun takes 365 days.

This is where we get to the understanding of the Jewish calendar, and you can almost take out your calculator right here. I’m going to do it myself. So if a Jewish month is 29 and a half days—take out your calculators. This is my calculator, right? Right over here. We’re going to start. I’m going to type in 29.5 because that is how long it takes for the moon to revolve around the Earth, and I’m going to times it by 12. Because 12 lunar months should be a year, and uh-oh. Look what the answer is: 12 times 29.5 equals 354. Uh-oh, what does that mean? That means that there are 11 days, more or less—we’re talking generalities—between a lunar year, that’s 12 months, and a solar year, that is 365 days. A lunar year is 354 days, and a solar year for the Earth to revolve around the sun is 365 days. That means there is an 11-day discrepancy.

So this is very tricky, and this is also something very interesting when you look at the world and you try to understand, like, are all of these religion—like, is this real? I’ve always found it so fascinating. The Christian world, the Western world, essentially uses the Gregorian calendar, that is a solar calendar, and they deal with this by adding in a leap year. The Islamic world uses a lunar calendar, which is why Ramadan can really travel throughout the calendar. Why is that? It’s because of that 11-day discrepancy. If you only have lunar years, that means 12 months of just 29 and a half days. So, you know, let’s say Ramadan on year one falls out Pesach time. Year two it will be 11 days earlier, year three will be 22 days earlier, year three will be 33 days earlier That’s now a month earlier. Nine years later, it’s now three months earlier.

So if you only have a lunar calendar, so what’s going to happen? It’s going to get earlier and earlier and earlier, and we see this in Islam. Ramadan travels throughout the entire calendar because they use a lunar calendar. The Gregorian calendar is solar. What’s the downside of the Gregorian calendar? It always preserves—you know, springtime is always going to be in April because the seasons go according to the sun. The summer is going to begin in, you know, June, July, August. You’re going to have winter, you know, January, February. That’s all intact. The problem with the solar calendar is that February 1 or April 1, the months don’t correspond at all to the moon cycles. Meaning when we have a new moon, it doesn’t mean on our secular calendar that we can actually phase it to the moon cycles.

The Jewish calendar combines both. We have a lunar-solar, or is it solar-lunar? I think it’s lunisolar. I don’t know why. Solar-lunar. Lunar-solar. They’re all great by me. The Jewish calendar does both, which means when we have a new month, it corresponds to the actual moon phases. So in the beginning of a new month, you finally see that first little sliver of a C. You know, it goes this way, and then at the end of the month, you’re going to see a little sliver of a backwards C. We correspond to the actual months.

Now, there is a problem. We don’t use just a lunar calendar. That is Islam. We use a solar-lunar calendar. Why is that? That is an explicit verse. The verse says in Deuteronomy, in the beginning of chapter 16, there’s a commandment of sorts where it says, Shamor, watch, be careful, guard, es chodesh ha-aviv, the month that falls out in the springtime.

What do we derive from here? We derive from here that the months need to remain attached to the seasons. Shamor, watch, es chodesh ha-aviv. Chodesh is lunar. Ha-aviv is springtime. But we want them to be together. We want months to fall out in specific seasons, which is why we have a cycle and a system where we add an extra month onto our calendar. It’s not every year. It is actually a 19-year cycle, seven of which have added months, 12 of which do not have an added month. By adding this month, that helps the discrepancy of the 11 days.

Now, I want to explain which month do we add. The only month that gets an additional month is the last month before Passover, and that is the month of Adar. That is also explicitly derived in the Talmud, that Adar is really the only month that we double. So some years, in this 19-year cycle, where seven years are going to have not just one Adar, but two Adars.

Now you might be asking yourself why, a 19-year cycle, seven of them have two Adars, and 12 of them only have one Adar, kind of like a regular year? That has to do, if you do the math, that 19 solar years is actually fairly close to 235 lunar months. It works out almost exactly the same amount of time. So the 19-year cycle helps ensure that the sun and the moon, the seasons and the months, remain intact.

And that is the idea behind the Jewish calendar. The Jewish calendar is reconciling both the lunar cycle, which is the 29 and a half days it takes for the moon to revolve around Earth, as well as the solar cycle, which is the 365 days where it takes the Earth to revolve around the sun. How do we deal with that, the 11-day discrepancy between the lunar cycle and the solar cycle? That is exactly why the Torah warns us, Shamor es chodesh ha-aviv, make sure that your months don’t fall out of sync with your seasons. How do we do that? We have a 19-year cycle. Seven of those years, we add a second Adar. So in the Jewish calendar, you’ll have what we call an ibbur year. An ibbur year means an intercalated, I think that’s the word, where we add on an extra month, but we call it ibbur, which literally means pregnancy, and we’ll talk about that. And we combine that with the solar calendar, making the lunar-solar calendar, where both months and seasons are always in sync and represented, and that is the Guinness Book of World Record-awarded calendar of the Jewish people.

I am so excited to continue our journey through Tractate Rosh Hashanah, and let’s together keep making Torah sweet.

Go deeper