Rabbi Yisroel Kaminetsky: Learning in My Rebbe’s Voice
Nearly thirty years after ninth grade, Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin reunites with the rebbe whose voice he still hears when he learns Talmud.
In this episode of Talmud Daily: Voices, Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin revisits Tractate Beitzah with the person who taught it to him in ninth grade, Rabbi Yisroel Kaminetsky. Nearly thirty years later, Rabbi Bashevkin can still recite lines of Beitzah in his rebbe’s voice. When he and his friends studied for exams, that was how they said the words to each other.
“Read until it stops making sense.” That was Rabbi Kaminetsky’s advice to a roomful of boys trying to figure out where a sentence ends on a page of Talmud with no punctuation. Why start with Beitzah? The boys already knew the joy of Yom Tov from home. Here was a chance to discover what went into making those holidays, in a tractate short enough that a motivated ninth grader could finish it.
Together, Rabbi Bashevkin and his rebbe explore what a teacher hopes a student will carry out of that classroom. Every morning we ask God to make Torah sweet for us. How does a child come to taste that sweetness for himself?
Read the full transcript
Transcripts are produced by Sofer.ai and lightly edited—please excuse any imperfections.
Dovid Bashevkin: It is my absolute privilege and pleasure to introduce, to discuss tractate Beitzah, my rebbe from ninth grade when I learned tractate Beitzah, still my rebbe today, Rabbi Yisroel Kamenetsky. Thank you so much for joining Talmud Daily.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It is a great pleasure, always a great pleasure to talk to you, especially talking to you about one of my real passions, with somebody who was with me early in my career.
Dovid Bashevkin: I wanted to start where I was in ninth grade.
I joined the yeshiva, it was in its second year, and in ninth grade, we studied tractate Beitzah in your class, in your shiur. And I wanted to talk not only about Beitzah, but really the experience of teaching high schoolers, but I was wondering if you could remember why you chose tractate Beitzah as the ninth-grade tractate that’s going to like introduce us to more serious Talmud study.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It’s a great question. One might even say that Beitzah might be a little bit more off the beaten track of the standard tractates studied in the classic yeshivos.
The reason we selected it is that Beitzah is very much about the laws of Yom Tov, the laws of holidays. And holidays, you know, Maseches Shabbos talks about Shabbos, but Beitzah is all about Yom Tov, and similar to Shabbos in the sense that Yom Tov is such a joyous and special time for Jews, and to be able to like dig down into the nuts and bolts of Yom Tov, albeit, you know, Beitzah certainly speaks mostly about a lot of the negative things, but there’s also a lot about the joy of Yom Tov and the spirit. So our yeshiva is very much into trying to excite people about Judaism and about exciting them particularly about learning and about Gemara. So I thought that something that studies a lot about the laws of Yom Tov and connecting to holidays, I thought would be something.
There’s one other factor, actually, is that Beitzah is one of the generally shorter masechtos as masechtos go, and therefore, we always like to try, for those kids who are really motivated, maybe through bekius programs, through some quicker study, different styles of studying, but through a quicker style of study, perhaps they could even complete it. And to be able to, I know that part of the goal here with the Talmud Daily is to, in a certain sense, complete all of the Talmud, so we also had that goal a little bit, that Beitzah is somewhat shorter, so maybe throughout the year, in some way, again, I was just starting, I didn’t really know what that way would be, but I wanted to give the opportunity, the option to try to finish it.
Dovid Bashevkin: 1,000%. So one thing that I remember from your class, there are two things that really jump out at me.
One, literally, the jumping, the way that you would teach. I remember the first time I saw you teaching Gemara, or as we call it on Talmud Daily, Talmud, it was almost like you’re like watching like a 3D movie. It’s almost like startling. I was an eighth grader, and we would come in to your Talmud class, and it was just seeing somebody so young at the time, I’m sorry, rebbe, this is a long time ago, who was jumping around the classroom and teaching was something really remarkable.
But something else that I remember was you actually taught in a very stripped-down way, not a lot of sheets, not a lot of like home aids. You really wanted us to get comfortable in the world of a classical Talmud page. You know, the way that you would teach reading, this is going back more than 20 years, you would say, “Read until it stops making sense.” There’s no punctuation in the Talmud. So what I really wanted to hear from you is almost an inside look.
How, if at all, has your teaching style changed? You still teach a ninth-grade class, so the audience is the same, but in what ways have you changed in the way that you introduce Talmud to ninth graders?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: That’s a pretty wide-ranging kind of a question. In terms of the excitement and the passion, honestly, Talmud for me is a love of my life. I’ve now been studying the Talmud for 50 years. I actually started studying Talmud when I was nine years old.
It’s really the love of my life. There’s nothing I enjoy more. We just got out of Simchas Torah, and my voice is only at like 50 or 75% because I lead all the singing throughout all the hakafos on Simchas Torah, and I have to hold myself back. Literally, when I’m teaching, I’m so excited about it.
I get so into it. The Daf Yomi shiur in the morning, I tell myself, “Kamenetsky, calm down.” It’s, but I get so excited about learning. I love teaching Gemara, it’s like a real passion for me. It’s interesting.
It’s some mixture of my own real excitement and passion, and my understanding that in order to get kids excited about it, a lot of times they’re going to feed off of my excitement. And the truth is, it could be that the thing that I’m teaching them that’s most important is not even the text itself, but it’s my excitement about the text. That that’s certainly one of the things that comes across, that they should see how much I value and am excited by it. But you asked another very important question.
So to me, as a ninth-grade teacher, having kids know how to read the words inside and how to decipher the text is so crucial for Talmud because it doesn’t come with punctuation, And although now you actually can purchase editions of the Talmud that actually do have it, when we were learning, it didn’t exist actually, right, punctuation, or with the vowels and the punctuation, but now you can actually purchase and there are some actually classes in our yeshiva that do use those editions that come with the punctuation and the vowelization, all those things. But I don’t use those because I teach a little bit of a more honors section and I’m trying to get the kids to have the entire world of Jewish learning open to them. And the truth is that the Talmud in many ways is like an opening. It’s an entranceway, it’s like a gateway to the whole world of Jewish learning: the rishonim, the commentaries, achronim, the halacha, the Jewish law, when it comes at you could really trace not everything, but almost everything in Jewish law you can trace back, its roots came from the Talmud.
So teaching the kids how to be comfortable with the text and familiar with the text, a lot of that hasn’t changed. I will tell you one thing that really has changed, especially since your class, and that that really happened when we brought somebody in to teach our rebbeim how to teach. And the rabbi’s name was Rabbi Zelig Prag. If I’m not mistaken, he may still be teaching Gemara.
It’s really incredible he’s he’s like the dean of all Talmud teachers. He was teaching the Yeshiva of Flatbush and he asked one simple question. He said, “What do you want the kids to walk away from your year with?” And we all said, “I want them to know how to read.” He says, “Well, how come on your exams, you’re just asking what the Gemara say, they can read the English ArtScroll and get the gist of it, and not really develop the tools?” So I changed, since I taught you, I changed, and the guys read everything inside before I say anything. The kids read, and they break their teeth a little bit, but that’s the way you get better at it.
You get better at it by delving into it, by spending, my dear friend, our dear friend Rabbi Storch, you know, always quotes the idea that Malcolm Gladwell famously said that to be an expert in anything, you have to spend 10,000 hours. There’s no there’s no area that it’s more apparent to me than the study of Talmud, which when you first approach it, it’s like Mars, it’s like something totally strange, but once you develop, you get good at it. My other example that I like to say is that my guitar teacher, I’m a musician a little bit, and I remember when my guitar teacher taught me bar chords. First, I was like sure, when he taught me one bar all of a sudden, in one day, I went from knowing two or three chords, all of a sudden, he showed me that with one move, I can make 15 chords.
So the learning Gemara is like playing guitar. Like in the beginning, just to stretch your fingers on the frets is like so difficult, but once you go through the hard work of the basics, all of a sudden you could all of a sudden become like really good at it, you know, after you invest efforts. But to answer your question, the root idea of having the kids read everything, I give weekly reading quizzes that the kids record themselves saying over the text and I grade them on it, so I want to teach them, and they gotta listen to the way I read, they read it first, but I help them and I sort of like conduct a symphony in the class of every boy reading. Every boy in my class reads inside every day.
Now, every kid, it’s not just a passive listening, it’s every boy is actually getting into the guts of it and reading.
Dovid Bashevkin: There’s something really remarkable about the passion that you brought to it. I was in your shiur in DRS in the year 1999, so we’re more than 20 years later, and I, to this day, I don’t know it all by heart, but I can recite lines off the top of my head in your voice on Maseches Beitzah, meaning ha mechashev ha medida ba’i, which is you’re going to approximate it, we need an exact count. And you would jump up and say it with such intensity and joy that I remember when I would study the exams with Motti Gottlieb, who was the guy who you’d want to be studying with when I was in your class, we would do it in your voice.
And here I am, close to 30 years later, and I can still recite it. But a question that I’ve always had is really the unique and specific challenge of teaching ninth graders. Surely, you have been learning Talmud for long enough and at high enough level that you could really be teaching any age. You could be teaching in a gap year program in Israel, you’re not just a rebbe in DRS, you’re also the menahel.
So you could have self-dealt to yourself any shiur that you wanted, and yet you chose, specifically, I think, to teach in ninth grade, not because you couldn’t have given a higher level class, older students, college-age, post-college, beis medrash. I’m curious for you what it feels like and why you’ve decided to spend your entire focus and career on teaching Talmud specifically to ninth graders.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: Yeah, I will be honest and say I have rethought that from time to time, asking, maybe my talents would be better served with older kids, but what I always come back to is, in our system, most of the kids will get their first taste of Talmud, let’s say, in around sixth grade, seventh grade. It’s a taste that begin to get familiar with it.
Eighth grade, it gets a little bit, a little bit more serious, but high school is really, it’s really a different level. One of the beautiful and amazing things about Talmud is there are layers upon layers of depth of understanding. You could understand on a very, very basic level, you could understand on a deeper level. But so the reason I positioned myself in ninth grade is that the boy first comes into yeshiva, and I want to help frame his perspective on Talmud, because Talmud study, as we both know, in the classic yeshiva world, and I I say yeshiva world, Israel, America, throughout the world, post-high school, Talmud study has become it’s everywhere, it’s ubiquitous, and in many ways, it’s certainly a central part of Jewish learning is the Talmud.
A lot of things stem from the Talmud, come back to the Talmud, the Talmud is really so central. I always say, in terms of the goals of our yeshiva, so two of the primary goals are that the boys should love their Judaism, and of those two, the second one is they should love learning, they should love Torah study. That’s a primary goal. That they should become lifelong learners, they should become lifelong people connected to want to learn, to want to learn more.
So I view the sacred responsibility of the ninth-grade teacher, which is the students’ first experience in high school of Torah learning, I take that responsibility on myself. I’m very passionate about Torah learning, and I’ve been doing it for a long time now, and I’ve been teaching it for a long time. I feel like the best use of my talents, at least for right now, at least for the last I’ve been teaching ninth grade now for 33 years. My first two years actually I used to teach at MTA prior to DRS, so my first two years I was in tenth grade, which is also a wonderful experience.
It was the second-highest track in tenth grade, and then for the last 33 years, it’s been first for three years the highest track in ninth grade in MTA, and now for the last 30 years the highest track in ninth grade, the most advanced track in ninth grade in DRS. But that’s because I view this year as literally opening a world to the boys, a world of serious Talmud study. I don’t want to say in-depth, it’s not in-depth on the same level as an eleventh or twelfth grader, but for a lot of kids even a dispute among the Rishonim in how to understand a word or a dispute between Rashi and Tosafos, or some Acharonim, even some more intense analysis, which I sometimes will give a little bit of a taste. Again, not like every day and not all the time because the kids are just they’re just getting into it.
I just gave an exam today, actually I gave a Gemara test today, the first Gemara test of the year, and, you know, some of the kids handled it great. I actually have 32 boys in my class this year. But some of them, you know, really struggled because they’re not used to They might have even gotten all 95s and 97s in their eighth-grade Gemara classes without even working, but when you get to high school, to master all this material is much more challenging. So I view that it’s a window, it’s a portal.
Ninth grade is a portal to open them and to excite them about the depth and the beauty, the majesty, the harmony of a page of Gemara, of the commentaries, of the tapestry that is the world of Talmud. So, I think it’s a very important age.
Dovid Bashevkin: You’ve been teaching for such a long time, and you’ve been teaching Talmud really for such a long time, and I need to just say how caring of a rebbe you were. You mentioned today that you gave a Gemara test, which you remember how competitive and type A I was.
One of my favorite memories from high school is you knew I studied with another student who was not the strongest student, but he would study with me because I had good notes and all that stuff, and you called me aside before giving back the tests, and you said, “I want you to be prepared. You got a lower grade than the student who you were tutoring, and just know I know how much you put in in even helping them.” I got a 94, and you would always have us write, I wonder if you still do this, on top of the test, how long did you spend studying. Do you still do that on the test?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It’s not a formal sometimes I do, especially if I know there’s a boy who’s struggling with his grades, I will put that on there because it’s important for me to know that a boy put all that effort in, and to me, it’s it’s much, much more, like in anything in life, it’s much, much more about the effort, and I want to consider that and take that into consideration. If he didn’t manage to apprehend all of the text and to understand things on the deeper level, but if he put the effort in, so that’s quite important as well.
Dovid Bashevkin: Do you have any sense about why some high school students take to Gemara and fall in love with it, and others go through the system and they’re never able to latch, they’re never able to really find themselves in long-term Gemara study? I mean you’ve had so many years of students pass through your classroom. What do you think it is? Is it just the academic personality, or are there other factors that really play a role in shaping one’s lifelong relationship with Torah learning?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It’s a fantastic question, really a great question. I would say that there are a number of people that may have an easier or more difficult time. What I found is that if you grow up in a home that values Talmud study, that values serious Jewish learning, it’s a lot easier for the child to get into it.
A lot of times times parents are role models to their kids and Gemara learning is difficult. I love to quote a rebbe who was in our yeshiva for many, many years that just to get through the simple explanation of one page of Gemara, he likes to say, is harder than the hardest AP course. As you said, there’s no punctuation and there’s no stops, and then even once you get the stops, how does this have to do with 10 lines before and how does this have to do with 10 lines after? There’s so much to know. At the same time, if you are dedicated, if you’re willing to put in the work, the overwhelming overwhelming overwhelming majority, Dovid, of of students that I’ve seen who are willing to humble themselves and lower themselves to like wade through the details and the hard, the difficult times, as I said about the guitar, it’s similar.
Most of them will end up getting through. A lot of it is a lack of motivation, like not seeing the value in it. You know, the classic, “Well, if one ox gores another ox, why the heck should that bother me in Woodmere in 2026? Or I’m learning some of these esoteric topics which I don’t find relevant.” People don’t like to learn things that are not relevant. And some people view the Talmud as irrelevant to their lives.
And in a certain sense, they may not be wrong if they define relevance as, is my ox going to gore another ox today or is a dead bug going to touch my my pizza today? Is that going to affect me in any way, shape, or form? But when you view the Talmud as the word of God, I should say the distilled and translated word of God the way the great sages of all the generations understood the Five Books of Moses, the Chamisha Chumshei Torah, and the Mishnah, and the way they took the Mishnah and elaborated and discussed it, and I will tell you, Dovid, one of the things that I every single year that I’ve taught for 35 years—this is my 35th year, thank God, bli ayin hara, my 35th year—every year, the first day of class, I teach the same thing: Why are we doing this? Why study Gemara? Is it for the intellectual sharpening? You’ll certainly get that, but it’s not for that. Is it for the mitzvah of talmud Torah? You certainly get a mitzvah every minute you learn, but it’s not for that. It’s to connect to God. It’s to connect to God.
And if the Five Books of Moses is the word of God, so Talmud is the thought process of God. It’s God’s thought process. It’s the description of how the rabbis think, “What did God mean with this? What did He mean with this? How did He mean with this?” You can’t know somebody and and develop a connection with somebody if you don’t know who they are. And the study of Torah, and particularly the study of Talmud, is God’s thought process and the themes and theories and thoughts behind the word, behind God’s word.
So once you can convince kids that that’s what we’re doing here, it’s not This is not math class, and I have nothing against math class, but this is connecting to God, and in a deep way. And the more effort you put in, and the more depth you get, the more understanding and the deeper and the closer you get, the more spiritual you get. I always quote this idea that the Torah is called the mashal hakadmoni, that the Torah is a description of God. Rabbi Schachter likes to say, “A description of a description of a description.
We can’t apprehend God. We can’t actually describe God, but Torah is the closest thing that we have to describe the different facets of who God is.” But maybe I went a little bit far afield there, but the idea is the people who get turned off from it, either they don’t have an appreciation for what it’s really about, and there is sometimes it does require a struggle. Rav Aharon Lichtenstein once said, “In high school, we teach kids just enough Gemara that they should hate it. We teach them just enough Gemara because it requires a lot of hours.” That’s why in DRS we have two hours a day of Talmud and 40 minutes a day of Chumash and Navi, because of this Rav Aharon Lichtenstein comment, because it requires so much time just to get a foot in the door of Talmud.
It’s not Hebrew, it’s a foreign language. So just to get a foot in the door requires a significant amount of investment, but the good news is once you invest in the guitar, if you’re willing to put in the time, the reward is incredible.
Dovid Bashevkin: There’s nothing better, and honestly, Rebbe, I remember when you gave that over. I remember being in your classroom.
I remember where in the classroom I sat, and—
Yisroel Kamenetsky: You were right right on my right end, on your left, left in the front front row in the right-hand side.
Dovid Bashevkin: Exactly. Trying to like trying to sneak, the rebbe shouldn’t see me, he shouldn’t see me.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: I saw you. I saw you, right on right right on my right side. I think two rows, not right next to the desk, right next to the next to the desk.
Dovid Bashevkin: That’s exactly where I sat, and I remember the classroom, and one of the amazing things about your classroom, and this is a perfect segue to shift into our Talmud questionnaire, there were two things that was unique about our classroom. One is something that you gave over, and one was just in the decorations of the classroom.
What was very amazing is that you put pictures of both classical rabbis and Jewish leaders from previous generations, but also you put the pictures of your own rabbeim on the wall mixed in with the more classical portraits, let’s say of the Steipler and the Chazon Ish, and mixed in that you had your actual personal rabbeim. And one of the thing that was very special about our year, which was very personal, was that you your grandfather, the great Dr. Joe Kamenetsky, who was the trailblazer of Torah Umesorah, passed away that year, and you spent every day in class after he passed, you would spend a little bit of time talking about him and your own mesorah, your own tradition of where you fell in love with Yiddishkeit. So we almost got a look behind the curtain, and that is a perfect segue to begin our first question on the questionnaire. Who do you consider your primary teacher of Talmud, and what did they teach you?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: There are really, I guess, two and a half primary ones.
I had the privilege to study three years, but much more than three years, with Rav Mordechai Willig, starting with my 11th grade year in high school. Rabbi Willig opened up the world of Gemara to me in a way that I had never been exposed to it before. We studied Maseches Kiddushin that year, and Kiddushin became my favorite masechta because I had the privilege of studying it with Rabbi Willig. I was with kids a year older than me, whatever it was.
It was another story how that happened. But in 11th grade, I joined Rabbi Willig’s class. And Rav Mordechai Willig has been not only the teacher of Talmud to me, but an incredible mentor to me, but really the world of Jewish learning opened it up to me. And the second one would be Rav Mendel Blachman from Kerem B’Yavneh when I went to study in Israel.
I had Rabbi Willig for two years in 11th and 12th grade, and then I had Rabbi Blachman for like, so a year and a half in the middle there. But Rav Blachman, he taught me about fidelity to the text, and the importance of the text, and not assuming you knew things when a lot of times we learn, we think we get the general gist of it, but you’re actually not actually on the mark, and there’s a certain precision that’s important in Talmud and learning, and this is God’s word. If you were in Rabbi Blachman’s class and you said something that wasn’t exactly correct, he would accuse you of attacking his mother. That’s the way that he would view it as.
He wouldn’t tolerate, you know, things that weren’t precise definitions. I learned that from him. You know, and I just want to throw out there also, it’s a little bit of a paradox, but one year when I studied Reb Elchonon Wasserman’s teachings, that had a big impact on me. Rav Blachman very much did not like Reb Elchonon Wasserman’s approach, but for me, it helped me a lot.
And Rav Soloveitchik, reading the Torah of Rav Soloveitchik and listening to how he would see what was under a text and what was behind a text. And by the way, Rabbi Willig and Rabbi Blachman both introduced me to the world of the Torah of Rabbi Soloveitchik. And that has been a game-changer for me, for my understanding, the depth of understanding, and the creativity in the understanding, and the precision, together with the beauty and the inspiration of it, is just something quite remarkable.
Dovid Bashevkin: And you did something amazing.
I don’t think this is the custom in DRS anymore, but it made a tremendous impression on me, even though as a ninth grader we probably found it very frustrating and annoying. But the first time Rav Mordechai Willig, your rebbe, came to visit our yeshiva, you insisted that every student wear white shirts and a tie. I assume you don’t do that anymore, but I want you to know it made a tremendous impression on us. We are now entering in the tradition that our rebbe is handing down to us.
You look messier when you ask high school kids to wear a tie than they wear draped down, so it was probably smart that you discontinued that, I’m assuming you did, but it was a very, very special experience to be a part of your mesorah. My next question, which you kind of touched upon already, but I’m curious, if you were introducing the Talmud to somebody for the very first time, where would you begin and how would you introduce that?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: I’d probably begin from the tractate of Berachos, the very first one, mostly because it’s very relevant because there’s a lot that affects the way we practice, the way we pray every day, starting from the morning, the Shema, the Shema prayer, the Amidah, the Shemoneh Esrei prayer, there’s a lot of that there. So it’s very fundamental, and it’s frankly a bit easier. There are portions of it that are a bit more understandable.
There’s also interesting stories mixed in with the text, which is one of the fascinating parts of Talmud, but it’s easier, it’s relevant. Like I said, to me, relevance is a big factor in people, that people should see that, hey, the Talmud talks about something that Just to make it a little easier and a little more—
Dovid Bashevkin: I love that answer, and definitely makes a lot of sense. You kind of already spoiled your answer for this one because we know it, but we’re just going to ask it anyways, part of the questionnaire. What is your favorite tractate?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It is Maseches Kiddushin, although I will say I haven’t studied it in some time, but in my earlier years of Talmud study, it somehow this is what happened: I studied Kiddushin in 11th grade with Rabbi Willig.
Then I went to Kerem B’Yavneh two years later, and they were studying Maseches Kiddushin. And then when I became a rebbe in MTA the first year, they were studying Maseches Kiddushin, or one of the years was Kiddushin, maybe it wasn’t the first year, but one of the years. And then it was the last year actually. And then when I started DRS, Kiddushin was what I knew best, so I started with Kiddushin again the first year.
So I taught it so many times and a lot of times just the familiarity and to be able to delve deeper into it. And each time you learn, the thing about learning is that when you learn something once, that’s just like the prep, you know. On Simchas Torah, as soon as we finish Vezos Haberachah, we go right into Bereishis because the goal of learning is not the finishing. It’s not the Vezos Haberachah, it’s the Bereishis.
I think they say Reb Chaim Brisker used to take Chasan Bereishis, not Chasan Torah. Because now that I amassed all this wisdom, let me take that wisdom and now attack it a second time, because you’re going to learn it on such a much deeper level. So each time I study Kiddushin, it was more joyous, it was more I learned it deeply, understood it even better. So I think it’s mostly about that, but it’s also there are portions of it that are a little easier.
I’m not saying this out of humility, I’m saying it being honest, but I’m not the world’s most intelligent human being. My IQ is not I don’t have such a high IQ. It’s above average, but it’s—
Dovid Bashevkin: Okay, we’ll edit this part out, rebbe.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: I’m not I’m not I’m not brilliant, so to me like I need things presented to me in a clear, straightforward kind of a way, and like actually, every time I learn something, I get better, and I get better at it, and I understand it even more deeply.
So that’s why I think Kiddushin early on really really really fell in love with it. Oh, by the way, I didn’t mention this. Hold on, I didn’t mention this. Just remembered.
In seventh grade, my family tried to make aliyah for the year. In seventh grade, I went to a chareidi yeshiva in Israel, which turned out in many ways to be a mistake for various reasons. I think my parents didn’t realize what was happening, but it was a chinuch atzmai Talmud Torah in Bayit VeGan. And in seventh grade, I learned 40 blatt of Kiddushin, the second and third perakim and fourth, second, third, and fourth, from mem to the end.
My love story with Kiddushin happened already from seventh grade. I had a great rebbi, actually, and most of that year was a disaster for various other reasons, but on the Gemara-level learning, I learned 40 blatt of Kiddushin in—
Dovid Bashevkin: In seventh grade?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Dovid Bashevkin: Wow. I appreciate that a lot.
My favorite masechta is also the one that I learned in all of the different yeshivas that I was in, so it makes a lot of sense. Do you have a favorite story in the Talmud?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: One of them, it’s a tragic story, but it’s a very powerful story, the story of Rebbi Yochanan and Reish Lakish, the story of where Rebbi Yochanan and Reish Lakish, who were the incredible rebbi–talmid duo, and you can find their names on pretty much almost every page of all the Talmud, which is incredible if you think about it. And just the story of what, you know, brought them apart, they had an argument over something, and unfortunately, maybe Rebbi Yochanan had said something, you know, maybe that he regretted later saying, and just they were so close, but they were so passionate. And Reish Lakish passed away, and Rebbi Yochanan was inconsolable after he passed away, and and basically said that the loss of his student caused him to not be able to learn on the level that he could.
What a description of that not only does the student need the rebbi, but how the rebbi needs the student. And, Dovid, honestly, one of the reasons why it was a no-brainer for me to take time, honestly, that I don’t have today, but to take some time to spend with you is because when a talmid comes to a rebbi and says, you know, “I want to talk,” I don’t care if it’s in front of 5,000 people or it’s in front of one person, it’s in front of nobody. When a talmid reaches out to a rebbi and wants to talk, so, to me, there is no greater joy for a rebbi than if a talmid feels that the time that they had together was meaningful. And Rebbi Yochanan, in that page of Gemara, communicated that in spades, o chavrusa o misusa.
And the tragic end of that is that Rebbi Yochanan ended up passing away as well because Pain. Because without his student, he felt he could not be and achieve and accomplish what he needed to accomplish. So that’s certainly quite a powerful and poignant story amongst some others. That’s really one of the most powerful.
Dovid Bashevkin: That is really incredible. I think you did share that over because so much of the story talks about Reish Lakish’s transformation from a thug and a robber into a Torah scholar, and I think you sometimes would look at us and remind us that however you look at yourselves now, if there’s hope for Reish Lakish, there’s certainly hope for you, wherever you are now in that angsty period of our teenage years. And you really are and have been a rebbi for my entire life. I am curious, when do you first remember falling in love with learning Gemara?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: I would give two answers.
There was the initial, but it wasn’t really real. And I think this is going to be surprising for people to hear this a little bit. The time that I really really fell in love with it, I did it for a lot of hours, you know, even in high school, and in my senior year, I would learn four hours a night aside from my learning during the day, but I really wasn’t connecting to it. Certainly, my experience in Israel in Kerem B’Yavneh, my two years there, also played a very important role.
Came back to YU, went to Rabbi Willig’s shiur again for another year, then Rav Schachter’s shiur for a number of years, definitely was interested. But the truth is really when I made it my own was even later than that, honestly. It was when I got married, and then I went to the Gruss Kollel for a year in YU’s Gruss Kollel, and I sat, and I had time, I was already more mature, I had been through it, I had seen it. And now, really making it my own and really learning in depth and really understanding it deeply, I really believe there were some elements of falling in love.
It was like a process for me. I don’t know if it was one particular time, but that year, I remember, wow, I’m never letting go of this. I’m never letting go of this. This is to me like the most precious gift.
Torah learning, and Gemara learning particularly on a deep level, as a precious gift, it was sitting there. It was like Gemara, Rashi, Tosafos, Ritva, and Ran, and and Rav Elchonon Wasserman, and listening to the Reb Elchonon Wasserman would analyze and the analysis back and forth, something about that year being in Eretz Yisroel just like I said, “I’m not letting go of this.” And to this day, Dovid, to this moment, I am the happiest when I have a Gemara open in front of me. That is my happy place. That is what gives me the most joy, and if there’s students in front of me, it’s even a thousand times more, but that’s my happy place.
And I learned to fall in love On the DRS Aron Kodesh, the pasuk is, “Pikudei Hashem yesharim mesamchei lev, mesamchei lev.” Torah brings joy. And a mourner is not permitted to study Torah because of the joy that Torah brings to somebody. And I have been blessed, I have been blessed to have Torah teachers and to be raised in a Torah home, like you pointed, my grandfather, my father, who were role models to me about the joy of Torah. And think about the people listening to be able to pass on, it’s so important.
I said a little bit in passing, but I want to maybe just double down on it a little bit because it’s so, so important. We say every morning, Birkas HaTorah, “God, please make Torah learning sweet for me.” Then we say, “Veni’anachnu vetze’etza’einu vetze’etza’ei amcha beis… kulanu yodei shemecha, kulanu yod- velomdei sorasecha lishma.” If you want your kids to fall in love with Torah learning, then then it’s got to be sweet for the parents. That’s what this blessing says every morning: “God, please make it sweet for me.” And if it’s sweet for me, there’s a good sh- It’s not always like that, there’s no guarantee, it’s not absolute, but most often, if Torah learning is sweet for parents, and the kids grow up in an atmosphere where Torah learning is the most precious and beautiful, and you’re sharing words of Torah at the Shabbos table, or you’re discussing things of Torah, if that’s what’s sweet for you, veni’anachnu vetze’etza’einu vetze’etza’ei amcha, generally what happens is, if it’s sweet and beautiful and enjoyable for the parents, I was so lucky.
I grew up in a home I watched my father studying Torah all the time, and I know you did, too. You had a father who studied Torah and you had a grandfather—
Dovid Bashevkin: Yeah. My grandfather.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: —who studied Torah. When you grow up in that atmosphere, and maybe for the people listening, even if your parents didn’t, or grandparents, but you can start a tradition by the joy of Torah learning, you’ll see, I believe in most cases, where the jo- Torah study is joyous for parents, you’ll see the children, the grandchildren. So, I think that all those factors had a big goal, had a big part in my own, you know, love for it.
Dovid Bashevkin: Do you have a favorite personality in the Talmud, whether it’s a a person, a rabbi, somebody who’s quoted in the Talmud, do you have a favorite?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: Honestly, I love it all. I love it all.
I love every last I can answer this question in in a number of different ways. You really try not to play favorites. Maybe I’ll say like this: I’ll tell you, I give a Daf Yomi shiur and one of the participants has introduced me to the world of of the Amora Rav Yosef. Rav Yosef, the Amora who got sick and lost his learning, and his student would always try to remind him, Abaye was his student, and tried to always rem- “But Rebbi, but Rebbi, you told us.” But this person, Rav Yosef, who despite all of his sicknesses and illnesses and forgetting, he stuck with it.
I remember my grandfather, Dovid, you mentioned before, Dr. Joe, when he was at the end of his life, he was already in his 80s, and he suffered from dementia. And for a number of years, he suffered from dementia, and he lived next door to a beis medrash. He was already not even understanding most things. Every single day, he had his aide, it took him to get next door from his house to the beis medrash, which was I think two doors down, it took him about 30 minutes to walk two houses when he was like in his 80s.
But he said, “That’s where I’m going to be. I need to be in the beis medrash.” He would sit in It was a yeshiva two doors down. He would sit there. Somebody would learn with him, and he would listen to the guys learning, and he loved it.
He thrived, even though he understood at that point dementia very, very little. But to bring himself to the beis medrash. So the figure of Rav Yosef, who stayed with it, even he was one of the great of the Amoraim, and he would debate his student Abaye all the time, but he stuck with it even through illness. The Rambam writes even if a person is ill and sick, he’s still obligated to study Torah because Torah is not only about the knowledge and the understanding.
Rav Soloveitchik said it’s also about the experience. It’s also about the effort and the energy. It’s part of the experience. So, Rav Yosef in a certain way, and I’ll credit one of my talmid who’s really in many ways my rebbe, Mordechai, Mordechai Kurschner from my Daf Yomi shiur.
It’s not that I didn’t know this about Rav Yosef, but he always calls attention to Rav Yosef, who stuck with it through thick and thin, even through illness, even through forgetting, he still stuck with the Talmud and tried and tried to teach and tried to be there until his very, very end. So that’s very inspiring for me.
Dovid Bashevkin: That’s so moving, and it reminds me when we were in your shiur, aside from talking about your grandfather, you used to describe to us Rav Aharon Soloveichik, who was the younger brother of Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik, who you mentioned earlier. And Rav Aharon Soloveichik at the end of his life, I never saw him, but you grew up watching him, and it was very difficult for him to walk, and you used to describe in detail of both how slowly, but he would do it with joy in order to go and study and teach Torah.
It’s remarkable that still infuses that passion, that excitement, that commitment still courses through your veins, and it’s something anybody can appreciate, which leads leads me to my final question: When and where do you most enjoy learning Gemara?
Yisroel Kamenetsky: Gotta give a little shout out to my wife. We’ve been living in this house that I’m sitting in right now, we’ve been living here since I think around 1999, so it’s around—
Dovid Bashevkin: I remember when you moved in, sure.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: It’s been 27 years in this house. For the first 10 or 15 years there was no dedicated space in this house for my learning.
I used to go to the DRS beis medrash, which is only five blocks away, and go learn there very often, and my wife felt strongly that I deserve to have a study in the house. Used to call it the Kotzker room, Kotzker room. They say about the Rebbe of Kotzk, the Kotzker Rebbe, that towards the end of his life he disappeared, he locked himself away in a room where he just studied and meditated on God, and they would slip him food. I could maybe show the viewers a little bit.
Oh no, I don’t know, I’m not such a technologist, but basically I sit in a room, I’m surrounded, it’s not a large room, it’s maybe eight feet by ten feet, it’s not a large room, but this is a room where there’s sefarim. I’m sorry about my shelf, what do you call those, shelfies? My wife said, “How are you going to show the shelfie on the thing? It’s all messy.” I said, “I know, but it’s—”
Dovid Bashevkin: No, it’s great, Rebbe, we love it.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: “I know, I know, I know.” But it’s wall-to-wall. Every spare inch in this room is a sefer.
Not all of them that I’ve read, by the way, but just being surrounded in this room by my sefarim, and especially I would say, Shabbos afternoon, just a little secret, I have never, with rare occasion, but in my 59 years, I don’t sleep on Shabbos afternoon. I never sleep on Shabbos afternoon. Shabbos afternoon is my time for learning. Shabbos is my learning day.
From early in the morning till late at night, I don’t always post what I read over Shabbos, I don’t always post that, but it would be boring. Today I did, you know, Bechoros daf chaf daled and yesterday I did Bechoros daf, but, you know, sitting on Shabbos in this room, sometimes with a little cup of tea in the morning, early in the morning before davening, I don’t eat before davening. If I was able to have cake, then it would be like a different, different level. But with a little cup of tea in the morning and preparing, I usually give two drashos every Shabbos morning.
I run a minyan where I give two drashos every morning, and then I have to prepare Shabbos‘s daf, which I give on Motzei Shabbos, and then Sunday’s daf, and then prepare for yeshiva, you know, my Shabbos is packed. And because during the week I’m quite busy running a large organization, I don’t really get to learn in the afternoons. I give a shiur from 9:00 to 11:00, but let’s say from 12:00 to 6:00, I’m not learning that much in the afternoon. I try to learn at night, I do prepare at night, but in the afternoon I’m really running a business, running a yeshiva.
It’s a labor of love, but it’s, you know, it’s work.
Dovid Bashevkin: Yeah.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: So Shabbos is really my day to connect with my first love, which is Torah. So I don’t sleep Shabbos afternoon.
I do go to sleep pretty early on Friday night. I got to catch up on sleep. Sometimes I go, I go to sleep very early Friday night. But Shabbos is my day to really connect with learning.
So learning in this room, my wife’s donation to me, my Kotzker room, together with my sefarim, with my good friends, my sefarim here, and trying trying to connect on a deep way, that’s my happy place.
Dovid Bashevkin: Nothing better. Rebbe, I am so grateful. I know how busy you are, and really allow me to take the opportunity not just for coming on on a busy on a Sunday, on a busy day, but for your passion, for your care, for your sensitivity, for watching me literally grow up and never really losing faith in me.
I’m so grateful for you joining today and all you’ve done. Thank you so much for joining Talmud Daily.
Yisroel Kamenetsky: Forget about not, maybe we’re off the recording, but maybe you’ve got to include this also, forgetting about not not giving up on you, but how incredibly proud we are of the fact that you are teaching Talmud to thousands of people. Maybe you’re second to Reb Eli Stefansky, teaching Talmud to thousands of people, how incredibly proud personally and on behalf of the yeshiva, which is why I would never miss the opportunity to talk to you and to share with you and to help you do the incredible avodas hakodesh that you are doing.
It’s my privilege and thanks for having me, and we should always get together for good things and to celebrate Torah and celebrate Yiddishkeit together.