Hi friends, and welcome back to Talmud Daily, our 40-week tour throughout the entire Talmud. And today, we’re continuing our journey through Tractate Beitzah.
And today, I want to discuss a little bit of a niche, but fascinating historical issue that still roils to this very day, and it emerges both Talmudically, conceptually, in our very tractate. And I want to begin by rereading the verse that says that on Yom Tov, there’s an exception that you are allowed to prepare for food. And we read that verse earlier, and it says as follows: Uvayom harishon, on the first day of the holiday—that’s the first day of Passover, the first day of Shavuos, the first day of Sukkos—mikra kodesh, it has to be holy, that means that we abstain from doing those categories of work, what we call the 39 melachos. Those are the operationalized categories of work. Uvayom hashvi’i, not just the first day, also on the seventh day, mikra kodesh yiheyeh lachem. So on the first day and the last day are formal Yom Tovs, and those are days where we do not do any sort of work, except, the verse continues, kol melacha lo ye’aseh bahem, you don’t do any of these operationalized categories of work. Ach, except, asher ye’achel lechol nefesh, that which you need to feed, food. Fresh, delicious food, as we explained from Rashi, is permitted to prepare on Yom Tov itself.
But one thing is very strange in this verse. It says the first day, and it says the last day. But if you are familiar or if you have friends or family, particularly in the Orthodox community, who observe Yom Tov, you will notice that they will talk about—especially those in the diaspora, particularly, exclusively, those in the diaspora—they will talk about two days of Yom Tov.
Wait a second, I just read the verse. It says one day in the beginning, one day at the end. Where did we get this idea that we keep two days of Yom Tov? We have not one day in the beginning and one day at the end. we have two days in the beginning and two days at the end. Where did that second day of Yom Tov emerge from? So this has to do with both halacha:Talmudic, how we explain it, how it emerges from the Talmud. And also a little bit of exciting Jewish history.
So let’s begin with the basics. This has to do with the calendar and how we figure out how the Jewish calendar works. If you notice, this question never comes up on Shabbos. There’s nobody who keeps two days of Shabbos, because Shabbos is a very consistent cycle of the seven-day week, and at the end of the week, we have Shabbos, and then another six days of work, and then we have Shabbos.
Yom Tov is always described as a particular day on the calendar, and always in a particular month. Now here’s the problem: the way that we knew when a new month would begin. How do we know when there’s going to be a new moon? The moon eventually disappears, and we see a new moon. So there was a practice, we don’t have it anymore, but in the times of the First Temple, the Second Temple, maybe even for a couple centuries after—we’ll get into the details a different time—they would literally have witnesses go out, look up and see, do we have a new moon? And those witnesses would go to the high court in Jerusalem and say, we have a new moon, and they would say, okay, this is the start of a new month, whatever month that is. Let’s call it Tishrei, because that is the month where a lot of holidays happen. That’s both Rosh Hashanah and Sukkos. But it could also be Nissan. We have Passover during that time. And you have to know when Nissan begins to know when the 15th day of Nissan is going to be. To know when the 15th day of Tishrei is going to be for the start of either Passover or Sukkot.
When we relied on actual witnesses, the problem was, the witnesses would come, and those who lived close to Jerusalem, or really inside the Land of Israel, they would have a system where they would spread the word really quickly. But what if you don’t live in Israel at all? What if you live all the way in Egypt, deep in Iraq, in Turkey? We had communities all over the world. Especially after the destruction of the First Temple, the Jewish community was very diffuse. So how did they find out? It could take a couple of days to find out. It could sometimes take weeks to find out. So how would they know precisely when the new moon was to figure out when to start their actual holiday?
Because of this, there was a custom that they would observe, because there was a doubt, let’s just observe two days. That way we know we’re sure. We know more or less when the new moon is going to come out, but because we don’t know precisely and we basically have a one-day margin of error, so they said, “We’re going to keep two days of Yom Tov.”
But what about now? It doesn’t really make sense. We have a fixed calendar. We’ll talk about the history of when that came about. That’s for Tractate Rosh Hashanah. But for right now, let’s assume we have a fixed calendar. If we have a fixed calendar, then okay, so like let it go. Why do we still have to do this?
So the Talmud, in fact, deals with this in Tractate, you guessed it, Beitzah. And in Tractate Beitzah, on page 4b, there is a very famous line that I will read to you now, where the Talmud asks, vehashta, and now, deyad’inan bekviya deyarcha. Now that we know, we have a fixed calendar, we know when Tishrei has started. We know when all the months are going to begin. We plan this out long time in advance. There’s no doubt at all. Well, the Talmud asks, mai ta’ama, what is the reason, avdinan, do we still practice, trei yomei? You can hear in the language. This is very classical Aramaic. Mai ta’ama. Mai instead of mah, which means what. What is the reason? Ta’am, ta’ama, is Hebrew and Aramaic. So what’s the reason? Why do we still keep two days?
So the Talmud answers, mishum deshalchu mitam, we got word from the scholars in Israel.Hizharu, be very, very careful. Be careful with what? Beminheg avoseichem biyedeichem, with the customs of your forefathers that you have perpetuated. There is a reason why it became universally accepted to have two days of Yom Tov in the diaspora, and be careful with that custom. Don’t just discard it the moment the reasoning isn’t there for you. Don’t just throw it away. Keep it going to instill and to appreciate the traditions that were handed down to us.
This is our current practice. We are, in fact, very careful, and in the diaspora, it has become almost universally accepted that Passover, Sukkos, and even Shavuos, these are all celebrated. The Yom Tov is always two days instead of one. So on Passover, it’s two days in the beginning, and then we have the seventh day, and then we keep an eighth day because of that old doubt of we didn’t know when the month will start. Now we do know when the month will start, but as the Talmud says, hizharu, be very careful with this. Don’t just discard universally accepted traditions. Don’t just throw them out the window. Nurture them, because there are other reasons for why this is happening.
Now, I just want to talk a little bit about the history, and then we’re going to come back to this underlying reason. One of the most fascinating debates that is still going on today, that emerged in kind of the beginning of the 16th century, was people were able to travel much more quickly. There were more boats. Travel was getting a little bit easier. It’s nowhere near where it is today, and the following question arose: What about somebody who just visits Israel for the holiday? I’m just going to be in Israel for Passover. I’m just going to be in Israel for Sukkos. Should that person also keep two days? They plan on returning back home. I’m a diaspora Jew. I want to visit Israel for Passover. So do I keep my custom of two days, or do I keep the custom of Israel and only keep one day?
This question was sent to the great halachic authority who really bound and codified all law to this very day, became a new starting point for all halachic discourse, and that is the figure known as Rav Yosef Karo, the author of, you guessed it, the Shulchan Aruch.
The Shulchan Aruch—which we will probably do a much more in-depth historical analysis of because it’s a very important work—but [it] became the compendium of daily halachic life. Whenever anybody asks a question—what do we do on Shabbos, what do we do on Yom Tov, what do we do about davening—the new starting point. People aren’t going back to the Talmud and trying to figure it out from scratch. There are too many commentators. We need the basic approach, and that basic approach was codified by Rav Yosef Karo in his Shulchan Aruch.
He didn’t just write a Shulchan Aruch. He had a collection of responsa. And in responsa number 26, I believe, Rav Yosef Karo is asked this question: What about if you’re visiting Israel, but you plan on returning? Do you keep two days of Yom Tov like you’re a diaspora Jew, or do you keep one day because at the end of the day you will be in Israel? And Rav Yosef Karo rules it is really a question of identity: Am I where I am, or am I where I come from? And this is almost a question of identity. Where I am, I’m in Israel. I’m in a one-day territory. But where do I come from, and where do I plan on returning to? A two-day territory.
And Rav Yosef Karo, especially then, think about it, said, your real identity is where you come from. What community do you belong to? That’s what shapes your halachic obligations, that still you are a diasporic Jew, so even if you’re visiting Israel, you should still keep two days. And, in fact, historically, there have always been separate services for people who are visiting the Land of Israel to have that second day of Yom Tov.
Now, this was not the end of the discussion. This question came up again in the 17th century with a great rabbi known as Rav Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi, or sometimes called after the name of his work known as the Chacham Tzvi. And I want to give a quick shout-out to Rabbi Yossi Levine who wrote this phenomenal work on the Chacham Tzvi published by Littman. It’s not that thick, you can really get through it. It is a wonderful book on a really important period of time right as modernity is really starting to emerge with the Jewish people. And he, in responsa, in his collected responsa known as She’eilos Uteshuvos—that means questions and answers, responsa. And the name of his responsa is called Chacham Tzvi.
Everybody has like their superhero name. That’s how I always think about it. You know, like rabbis are rarely called their actual names, especially historical rabbis. They’re either called some acronym, like the Maharal or the Rashi, Rambam, or very often they’re called after the names of their works. And the Chacham Tzvi is a classic example of that. Very few people will call him Reb Tzvi Hirsch Ashkenazi. Instead, they’ll call him, “the Chacham Tzvi says,” after the name of his work.
And he was asked the same question, and he gave a different answer. He says, “No, no, no, no, no. When you are visiting the land of Israel, now your identity, your halachic obligations follow where you are, not where you come from. Even though you are a diasporic Jew, even though you’re traveling from Turkey, from Egypt, from Florida, from the Five Towns, wherever it is, when you are in Israel, you only need to keep one day.”
Now, this is still being debated in communities, and that’s what’s so fascinating. And I would even say, within my own lifetime, I have noticed a beginning to tilt towards the Chacham Tzvi, where you have people who, even though they come from communities outside of Israel, while they are in Israel, they only keep one day.
But, of course, for your practice, don’t rely on me. Figure out. Ask a rabbi. Ask what people do in your neighborhood, in your community. That’s probably the right way to figure out how to proceed.
But I want to close with one idea that was said by the Tzemach Tzedek. The Tzemach Tzedek was the third Rebbe of Chabad. There are seven Rebbes in total in Chabad. The first Rebbe is known as the Baal HaTanya, Reb Shneur Zalman of Liadi. The second Rebbe was known as the Mitteler Rebbe, the middle Rebbe, even though he’s not really in the middle. He’s number two, was the middle Rebbe. The third Rebbe is known as the Tzemach Tzedek. There are four more. I’ll do them really quickly: the Rebbe Maharash, the Rebbe Rashab, the Frierdiker Rebbe, and then the Rebbe, that’s Reb Menachem Mendel Schneerson.
Tzemach Tzedek’s name was also Reb Menachem Mendel Schneerson. I think it was the Rebbe that we’re familiar with, great-great-great-great-great-grandfather. Like there was a direct descent. They were both named literally Menachem Mendel Schneerson. And the Tzemach Tzedek says something so beautiful. The deeper reason of why we keep two days in the diaspora and one day in Israel is that when you’re in Israel and you’re surrounded by this Jewish environment, to tap into the essence of Pesach, to tap into the essence of Shavuos, to tap into the essence of Sukkos when you’re in Israel, and people have experienced this, it only takes one day.
When you’re in Israel, you just feel the skies open up. Everyone around you is also practicing. It’s in the environment. It’s in the streets. It’s in the air. You only need one day to tap into the majesty and the power of the Yom Tov.
But it’s in diaspora where we walk out, and it takes a lot more to really feel that beauty of Pesach, to feel that serenity and power of Shavuos and Sukkos, of Yontif. So in the diaspora, says the Tzemach Tzedek, we need two days just to get the beauty and the majesty of the Yom Tov itself. We need more time to feel it.
And I’ll be honest with you, and my wife totally agrees with me, we always say we need two days. We need that second day. Life is so hectic. Modernity is so fast. The diaspora, you feel so distant. To really get into Passover, to really get into Shavuos, to really get into Sukkos, Rosh Hashanah, whichever Yom Tov is in front of you, we need that second day to fully unplug, to fully immerse ourselves in the value of each Yom Tov. One day is not enough. In exile, in the diaspora, we need two days.
So whatever your actual practice is, that’s a little bit of the history of how we came to celebrate in the diaspora two days of Yom Tov. So thank you so much for listening, and let’s together keep making Torah sweet.