Episodes / Moed · Rosh Hashanah · Thu
Day 59 of 164

A Home in Jewish Time

From a dispute over Yom Kippur to calendars drawn up in concentration camps, Jews keep finding ways to mark the months together.

10:11 · Nov 12, 2026
Hosted by Dovid Bashevkin
Day 58
Day 60
In this episode

Imagine being told to show up with your walking stick and your wallet on the day you’re convinced is Yom Kippur. That’s exactly what Rebbi Gamliel asks of Rebbi Yehoshua in Tractate Rosh Hashanah. The two disagree about when the new month begins. But once the court sanctifies the new moon, even if its calculation is off, the month begins.

In 922, Jews in Babylonia and the Land of Israel actually observed holidays on different days, and Rav Saadya Gaon fought for a shared calendar. Centuries later, Abraham de Sola and Jacques Judah Lyons printed a calendar with the second day of Yom Tov, even as some communities were dropping it.

And then there were the calendars from ghettos and concentration camps. On some, the date of Tisha B’Av is there, but its name is left blank. Think about that blank space. This was the day Jews set aside to mourn the destruction of both Temples. What do you write in that space when you’re living through a catastrophe yourself?

Still, even then, Jews worked out when the months began and when the holidays would come. Jewish time could still give them a place to come home to.

Transcript
Read the full transcript

Hi friends, and welcome back to Talmud Daily, our 40-week tour throughout the entire Babylonian Talmud, and this week we are exploring Tractate Rosh Hashanah, and today I want to talk about some of the history that emerges from this tractate.

And if you look on page 25a in Tractate Rosh Hashanah, you will see that there is a famous story, a disagreement between two rabbis, Rebbi Gamliel and Rebbi Yehoshua, over the calculations of the calendar. That was back in the day where they literally had witnesses come in and sanctify the new moon to know when the first of the new month was. And somebody came in and Rebbi Gamliel, who was really the leader of the Jewish community at the time, accepted their testimony and said it’s a new moon. There were other rabbis who were like, “Not so sure. Are you sure? Like it doesn’t really make sense that the month is starting now.” And they refused, and they said, “You know what? I think you might be wrong. Our calendar is a little bit off.” And Rebbi Gamliel made a very important point. He says, “That’s not how the calendar works. It works through the sanctification of the Jewish people. So if we sanctify the new moon, even if it was mistaken, even if we were off, it’s still sanctified, and the month begins.”

And Rebbi Gamliel said, “I want to make sure that we all still are bound by the same calendar. So I want you, Rebbi Yehoshua, to come to me with your wallet, with your walking stick, like it was a regular day, on your Yom Kippur,” which is like a wild thing. “When you think it would be Yom Kippur, I want you to come and visit me with your walking stick, with your wallet, with everything as if it was a regular day.” Why? Because it’s that important that the Jewish people remain bound by the same calendar. We may have geographic differences, we have different communities, we need to stay connected with the same calendar.

And this debate came up over and over again throughout Jewish history. In fact, it’s not just Jewish history. One of the major issues that came up at the Council of Nicaea in 325—this was a gathering of Christian scholars to really canonize and figure out like what do we believe in. One of the major agendas on it was how do we divorce ourselves from the Jewish calendar. The problem was is that the dating of Easter used to always rely on Passover. So the Christians were trying to like, “We don’t want to have to rely on the Jewish community to figure out when our holidays are. We need to figure out a different way.” So it’s not just that the calendar shapes the Jewish community. People want their own calendar. And the Christian world in the Council of Nicaea, one of the major issues on the agenda was divorcing Passover and Easter.

But this obviously continued within the Jewish world as well. In 922, there was a major debate between the Babylonian community and the Palestinian… back then it was called Palestine. It was renamed Palestine by the Romans after conquering the land of Israel, but the community that still lived in the land of Israel at the time, and they had a major debate. It was very, very technical, and trust me, you’re going to thank me later that I’m not going into the details, but it was really a debate over how the calendar should work.

There was one year, in 922, where the Jewish community in the diaspora and the Jewish community in Israel actually observed holidays on different days because they couldn’t agree on the calendar, until it was Reb Saadya Gaon who really laid down, said, “This cannot divide us. We need a calendar that binds the entire Jewish people.” And how right he was! Throughout the entire exile, we were all in disparate lands. We were under different governments, different emperors, different empires. The one thing that bound Jews no matter where you were was the Jewish calendar.

And I want to introduce you to an amazing book which really highlights how the calendar shaped Jewish identity, was written by my teacher, and I’m so grateful to her for her teachings, Professor Elisheva Carlebach, who wrote a book called Palaces of Time: Jewish Calendar and Culture in Early Modern Europe. And if you could tell by the cover, if you look at it, it’s absolutely gorgeous. There are incredible pictures throughout the book of these historical calendars. I’ll try to show you a few of these incredible pictures of historical calendars. I don’t know if you can get in there and really see the images, but she has all of these incredible calendars from all throughout Jewish history. These amazing, amazing images that show you how the Jewish people kind of negotiated living under a secular calendar as well as a Jewish calendar, and how they kind of made space for both, and made sure that they were able to do business, but still preserve Jewish holidays, Jewish culture, Jewish identity through our calendar.

One of the most amazing articles about a calendar controversy came up way, way later, in the 1800s, and that is an article that was written by my dear friend Professor Zev Eleff. And Zev Eleff wrote an article which you can find online called They Who Control the Time: The Orthodox Alliance of Abraham de Sola and Jacques Judah Lyons and the 19th-Century Jewish Calendar Controversy. This is really about the emergence of different communities of practice as different denominations or movements began in the Jewish world because of modernity. In the 1800s, there were many reformers, and that was kind of the early elders of Reform Judaism that we still have today. They were saying we need to reform the calendar as well. And there were those, who very early on, really in 1807 was the first time that the reformers in Westphalia actually voted and said, “You know what? Let’s get rid of the second day of Yom Tov.” And then what happened? They started to come out with a new calendar.

So in 1854, Abraham De Sola and Jacques Judah Lyons came out with a 50-year calendar, and they included both days of Yom Tov. And many people were upset because in America, especially back then, most of the population were on board with these reforms. They said, “Ah, we’ll get rid of it. We don’t need it anymore. Why is it even on the calendar?” In the 1840s in Charleston, they agreed with the vote that was taken in Westphalia, that was in 1807, and in Charleston it was in I think 1843. 1840, hey-oh.

This is when everyone was trying to figure it out. That’s why these years were so pivotal. Trying to figure out the models that were basically going to work to preserve Jewish life. And these two men came out with a calendar that included the second day of Yontif, and there were many people that said, “Are we going back to the old ways?” But thank God, they remained strong, and they said, “You know what? We need to preserve a uniform calendar. What your practices are going to be in your home, you can go ask community leaders, ask a rabbi, but we need to ensure that we have a unified Jewish calendar.”

As we mentioned in the beginning, Guinness Book of World Records, the oldest calendar still in use. And this was the debate that was coming out in modernity: should we reform and revise the calendar or still stick to kind of the classical Jewish calendar?

Now there is one other book, and this is actually kind of heartbreaking in the history of the calendar, that I want to introduce you to. I wish more people knew about this cuz this book really brought me to tears. It is written by Alan Rosen, and it’s called The Holocaust’s Jewish Calendars. And what makes this book so amazing is it talks about how Jews in the concentration camps, in the darkest places in the world, still endeavored to keep Jewish time. And what makes this book so amazing is he actually has pictures of the actual Jewish calendars that were developed, whether it was in the ghettos or even in concentration camps, that Jews, based on their basic calculations and knowledge of the Jewish calendar…

You too, maybe not after one season of Talmud Daily, but once you get the basics, you can develop your own Jewish calendar, knowing how all the months are going to fall out. Know which months are larger, which month have an extra day, which months don’t have an extra day, whether it’s a leap year or not a leap year. You’ll know the entire 19-year cycle, which we spoke about, 12 years without an extra month, seven years with an extra month to ensure that the months and the seasons always remain intact.

What’s so amazing about this book, and I’m showing you some of the pictures and I just find it so moving, is actually what they didn’t include on the calendar. In many of these calendars, they wouldn’t even include the Ninth of Av. The Ninth of Av is on the calendar the saddest day, the day of mourning when we mourn the destruction of both the First and Second Temple as a day of mourning. And in the Holocaust, on a lot of these calendars, they would leave it blank. They would recognize that it was a day, but they wouldn’t even say what it was. They were so broken. They were so disheartened. Even in that darkest place, though, Jews wanted to remain tethered to the redemptive identity that only comes through the calendar, where we don’t have to wander through time, even if we don’t have a place of land, even if we didn’t have a country, even in the darkness of the Holocaust, the Jewish calendar still provides a home of sorts, still remains tethered to the rest of the Jewish people throughout the world.

And that is the power and the majesty of the history of the Jewish calendar. And I’ll just read in conclusion the way my teacher, Professor Elisheva Carlebach, concludes her work, because you really see how the calendar is a repository of Jewish culture and Jewish history itself. And this is how she concludes:

“Editors and printers have used calendars to strengthen Jewish political identities as well as to educate, agitate, and advertise. Advertisements, and you may be familiar with this with your contemporary calendar, containing detailed information about the goods and services of Jewish-owned businesses allowed the calendars to continue their function of maintaining commercial networks among geographically dispersed Jews. From automobiles to toothpaste, every sort of commodity was advertised in their pages. Tailors, shopkeepers, matchmakers, and booksellers all found a place in ubiquitous calendars. Yet despite their close reflection of the time-bound elements reflected in their pages, the core of the calendar remained timeless. Easily overlooked, but abundantly preserved, calendars have served as mirrors and agents of change, as indexes of acculturation, and as matchless reflections of the Jewish experience over time.”

And that is the beauty of the Jewish calendar, which really is not just a way to keep time, it is a way to preserve Jewish identity itself. And with that, we’ll conclude Tractate Rosh Hashanah. Thank you so much for joining us on this Talmud Daily journey, and let’s together keep making Torah sweet.

Go deeper